Handmade Paper vs. Cardstock for Wedding Invitations: Which Is Right for You?

When it comes to designing your wedding invitations, one of the first choices you’ll make is selecting the type of paper. Your chosen paper sets the tone for your event and creates a tangible first impression. Among the most popular choices are handmade paper and cardstock—each offering a unique aesthetic and feel. Let’s discuss the key differences between the two, along with their pros and cons, to help you decide which is the best fit for your wedding paper vision.

Handmade Paper

Handmade paper is exactly as it sounds: paper crafted by hand, often in small batches, using traditional techniques. This results in paper with a soft, organic texture and natural deckled edges that are truly one-of-a-kind.

Pros of Handmade Paper:

1. Unique, Organic Texture: No two pieces of handmade paper are alike. The texture, thickness, and subtle imperfections give each piece a truly bespoke feel, perfect for couples wanting something unique.
2. Elegant, Vintage Charm: The deckled edges and tactile quality of handmade paper exude luxury and timelessness. It pairs beautifully with traditional printing methods like letterpress or foil stamping, adding to its heirloom quality.
3. Eco-Friendly: Many handmade papers are crafted using recycled or natural fibers, making them an environmentally conscious choice for eco-friendly weddings.
4. Perfect for Fine Art Stationery: Handmade paper pairs beautifully with vintage artwork and venue illustrations. It enhances the artistic details and elevates the entire invitation suite.

Cons of Handmade Paper:

1. Cost: Handmade paper is often more expensive than cardstock due to the labor-intensive process of creating it. If you’re working within a budget, this might be a consideration.
2. Printing Limitations: The uneven surface of handmade paper can pose challenges for some modern printing techniques like digital printing. However, traditional methods like letterpress and foil stamping often work beautifully.

Cardstock

Cardstock, also known as cover stock, is a thick and durable paper that comes in a variety of finishes and weights. It’s a versatile and popular choice for wedding invitations.

Pros of Cardstock:

1. Cost-Effective: Compared to handmade paper, cardstock is generally more affordable while still offering a polished, high-quality finish. This is ideal if you’re looking to allocate more of your budget elsewhere.
2. Durability: Cardstock is sturdy and less prone to damage during mailing, especially for complex invitation suites with multiple enclosures.
3. Versatile Printing Options: Cardstock works well with all types of printing techniques, from digital printing to foil stamping and letterpress. This gives you flexibility in both design and budget.
4. Variety of Styles: Available in different finishes (matte, glossy, textured) and colors, cardstock allows you to choose a paper that complements your wedding aesthetic, whether modern, rustic, or classic.

Cons of Cardstock:

1. Less Unique: While cardstock comes in a variety of finishes and textures, it doesn’t have the handmade, one-of-a-kind feel that handmade paper offers. It can feel more mass-produced by comparison.
2. Lack of Texture: For couples seeking a tactile, artisanal quality, cardstock may not provide the same sensory experience as handmade paper. Even textured cardstock can lack the depth and character of handmade paper.

Which Should You Choose?

The decision between handmade paper and cardstock ultimately comes down to your wedding aesthetic, budget, and the impression you want to leave on your guests.

• Choose Handmade Paper If: You want to create an invitation suite with a vintage, organic, and artful vibe.
• Choose Cardstock If: You’re looking for a durable, cost-effective option that still offers versatility in design. Cardstock is perfect for couples with a modern or minimalistic aesthetic, or those working within a specific budget.

Both options are beautiful in their own right and can be tailored to reflect your wedding vision. If you’re still unsure, it may help to request samples to see how each feels in your hands and how it pairs with your design choices.

No matter which paper you choose, your wedding invitations are the first glimpse your guests will have of your special day—and both handmade paper and cardstock can help you make that first impression memorable.

Pro tip:

I love incorporating both handmade paper and cotton cardstock into an invitation suite. For a stunning contrast, consider using handmade paper for your main invitation and cotton cardstock for the additional inserts. This blend creates a beautifully layered design and offers an unexpected, tactile experience.

At Ashley Bunten Design, we specialize in creating one-of-a kind wedding invitations, offering both handmade paper and high-quality cardstock options. We’re here to guide you through the process of selecting the perfect materials that reflect your style and the tone of your wedding day. Contact us to get started on your custom stationery!